Response Paper #3 Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words

Response Paper 3 - Essay Example onwards delving into the niceties of legal theory, it will serve us to first review the components of the statute that appellant Omeira stands convicted of contravening and, thereafter, applying those same components to the facts of the case. evidently stated, section 901.34(1), Wessex Code, the Native Art Protection Act (or NAPA), forbids export of native works of art produced onward 1920 and worth more than 100,000 pounds. The statute is quite specific. It does not address such matters as forgerytherefore a forged work of art (e.g., unlawful export of an ostensible work by the celebrated 15th deoxycytidine monophosphate Wessex master Harpo that was actually produced in the studio of the less appreciated 17th century Wessex sculptor Groucho) might well satisfy the three desiderata of the Act. The Act, however, does open up three elements that must be gratuity for the Act to be applicable in a specific case.First, the work of art in unbelief mu st be of Wessex origin. Second, it must have been produced before 1920. And, third, it must be appraised at more than 100,000 pounds. We whitethorn apply these specific desiderata to the work in question, Seminole Falls, ostensibly the work of the 18th century Wessex master Decameron, moreover now known to be a modern forgerythe product of Belgian landscape artificer Flammarion, to determine if the Act has been violated.First, Seminole Falls is not of Wessex origin. Evidence, bordering on the conclusive, points to its production in Flammarions Antwerp studio. Second, Flammarion did not establish himself as a prominent landscape painter until the mid-1960s. Therefore, Seminole Falls could not have been produced before 1920, a requirement necessary to implicate the Act. Finally, third, the value of the work has been established as less than 100,000 pounds. As our brother, nicety Newson, succinctly described it, An expert from the Arts Council inspected the painting and